THE GERMAN REALTOR · KAUFMAN REALTY & AUCTIONS
Homes for Sale in West Lafayette, Ohio
West Lafayette is a small village in eastern Coshocton County with a real Main Street, its own school district, and neighbors who show up for each other. It’s a place I know well, and here’s what I tell people who are thinking about moving here.
LIVING IN WEST LAFAYETTE
What It’s Like to Live in West Lafayette
West Lafayette was laid out in 1850, and today it’s a village of about 2,400 people covering roughly a square mile. Downtown still has buildings like the 1911 storefront that houses Brothers Hardware, and the village hall, schools, churches, and parks are all a short drive or walk away.
It’s the kind of town where you run into people you know at the hardware store, and where the Chamber dinner feels more like a get-together than a networking event. You’re only a short drive from Coshocton for bigger shopping, and close to US-36 and I-77 if you work in Tuscarawas County.
West Lafayette at a Glance
2,417
Residents
2020 Census count
3
Ridgewood schools
Elementary, middle & high, all in the village
7 miles
To I-77 at US-36
Per the village
$196,989
Average sale price
MLS Now, last 360 days
Sources: Ohio Department of Development, Census 2020 Population Counts; Village of West Lafayette; Ridgewood Local School District. The Census doesn’t publish QuickFacts home values for places under 5,000 people.
West Lafayette is a small market, so a handful of sales can move the numbers a lot. Here’s the current picture: an average sale price of $196,989 across 36 sales, with homes averaging 66 days on market (Source: MLS Now, last 360 days (as of Nov 2026)). You can see one recent example here: 304 E Russell Ave, West Lafayette – Sold.
West Lafayette Market Snapshot
66
Average days on market
MLS Now, last 360 days
36
Homes sold
MLS Now, last 360 days
1.8
Months of inventory
3.3 sales per month; 67% of listings sold
Source: MLS Now, last 360 days (as of Nov 2026). Months of inventory and the share of listings that sold come from the same MLS Now report. Past sales don’t predict future prices.
Housing in West Lafayette
Inside the village, you’ll mostly find single-family homes on regular lots: older two-stories close to downtown, plus ranches and mid-century homes on the side streets. Homes in the village are generally on village utilities, and you’re close to the schools.
Outside the village, Lafayette Township and the surrounding countryside offer homes on more land, some with barns or outbuildings. Those homes are more likely to have a well and septic system, so plan your inspections around that.
Close to downtown
Older homes within walking distance of Main Street, the hardware store, and local events.
Village side streets
Ranches and mid-century homes, often a good fit for first-time buyers or anyone who wants one-floor living.
Country around the village
More space and privacy. Ask about well, septic, driveway access, and which district the address is in.
Schools and Getting Around
Schools
The village is served by Ridgewood Local Schools, with Ridgewood Elementary, Ridgewood Middle School, and Ridgewood High School all in West Lafayette. The district works with the West Lafayette Police Department on a school resource officer program.
Want to see what the district is doing? I wrote about a Ridgewood student AI project. Country homes near the village can fall in other districts, so confirm for each address.
Commute and distances
According to the village, West Lafayette is about 2 miles south of the US-36 and State Route 93 intersection and about 7 miles west of where US-36 meets I-77.
That puts Coshocton roughly 15 minutes west and New Philadelphia and Dover about 35–45 minutes northeast, depending on where you’re headed.
Local Highlights
A few things that give West Lafayette its small-town feel:
Downtown West Lafayette
Main Street still has its historic storefronts, including the 1911 building that’s home to Brothers Hardware.
Village hall
Village council meets in the chambers beside the administration offices on East Railroad Street, so local government is close and easy to reach.
What neighbors say
“Matthias is friendly and helpful in real estate, community service, and as a neighbor in our village. He works hard for his clients and thinks outside the box.” – Jessy T., West Lafayette
Buyer Tips for West Lafayette
Write a clean offer
Good homes in a small village can get attention quickly. Here’s how to make a competitive offer in West Lafayette.
Plan for older systems
Many village homes are older. Look closely at the roof, furnace, electrical panel, and sewer line.
Country checklist
Outside the village, test the well, inspect the septic, and ask whether mineral rights transfer.
First time buying? Read my Complete Guide to Buying a Home in Tuscarawas & Coshocton Counties.
West Lafayette Home Buying FAQ
Is West Lafayette, Ohio a good place to live?
If you want a small village with its own schools, a historic Main Street, and easy access to Coshocton and I-77, many people find it a great fit.
How many people live in West Lafayette?
The 2020 Census counted 2,417 residents in the village of West Lafayette.
What school district serves West Lafayette?
Ridgewood Local Schools. Its elementary, middle, and high schools are all in the village.
How far is West Lafayette from I-77?
About 7 miles to the I-77 and US-36 interchange, according to the village.
Who can help me buy or sell in West Lafayette?
Call or text Matthias Sterzer with Kaufman Realty & Auctions at 740-610-8725.
Thinking About West Lafayette?
I’m Matthias Sterzer, The German REALTOR® with Kaufman Realty & Auctions. I’ll help you find the right house in the village or out in the country, and I’ll be honest about what each one is worth.
📞 Call/Text: 740-610-8725
📧 Email: matthias.sterzer@kaufmanrealty.com
OUR BROKERAGE
Kaufman Realty & Auctions
We’re proud to be part of Kaufman Realty & Auctions, a local name in real estate and auctions since 1975. Stop by the New Philadelphia office or give us a call.
Kaufman Realty & Auctions, New Philadelphia Office
224 Fair Avenue NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Office: (330) 602-4111
kaufmanrealty.com
Matthias Sterzer, REALTOR®
Call or text: 740-610-8725
Photo credits: Downtown West Lafayette (hero): Roseohioresident, CC BY-SA 4.0; Brothers Hardware: Roseohioresident, CC BY-SA 4.0; West Lafayette village hall: Roseohioresident, CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons photos cropped and resized. All other photos are from The German Realtor Team’s own media library.