THE GERMAN REALTOR · KAUFMAN REALTY & AUCTIONS
Homes for Sale in Sugarcreek, Ohio
Sugarcreek is a small village on the western edge of Tuscarawas County, right at the doorway to Ohio’s Amish Country. If you want a quiet place with real character and some land around you, it’s worth a look.
LIVING IN SUGARCREEK
What It’s Like to Live in Sugarcreek
People call Sugarcreek “The Little Switzerland of Ohio,” and you see why as soon as you drive into town. Swiss-style storefronts line Main Street, and one of the world’s largest cuckoo clocks stands right in the middle of the village. Horse-drawn buggies share the road with cars here, because Sugarcreek sits right in Ohio’s Amish Country.
It’s a small place, with around 2,400 residents, so life moves at a slower pace. You can still get to Dover and New Philadelphia in about 20–25 minutes for bigger shopping, the hospital, or I-77.
Sugarcreek at a Glance
2,373
Residents
2020 Census count
Garaway
School district
Garaway Local Schools
SR 39
Main road
To Dover and Holmes County
$339,393
Average sale price
MLS Now, last 360 days
Sources: Ohio Department of Development, Census 2020 Population Counts; Garaway Local Schools. The Census doesn’t publish QuickFacts home values for places under 5,000 people.
Sugarcreek doesn’t have many sales in a year, so prices swing with what happens to be for sale. Here’s the current picture: an average sale price of $339,393 across 29 sales, with homes averaging 57 days on market (Source: MLS Now, last 360 days (as of Nov 2026)).
Sugarcreek Market Snapshot
57
Average days on market
MLS Now, last 360 days
29
Homes sold
MLS Now, last 360 days
1.9
Months of inventory
2.7 sales per month; 74% of listings sold
Source: MLS Now, last 360 days (as of Nov 2026). Months of inventory and the share of listings that sold come from the same MLS Now report. Past sales don’t predict future prices.
Housing In and Around Sugarcreek
In the village itself, you’ll mostly find modest single-family homes, from older two-stories near Main Street to ranches on the side streets. Homes inside the village are usually on village water and sewer.
Outside town, in Sugar Creek Township and the surrounding countryside, it’s farmhouses, homes on a few acres, barns, and the occasional small farm. Homes with land don’t come up often around here, and they can draw interest from several directions, so it pays to be ready when the right one does.
In the village
Walk to Main Street, the clock, and local shops. A good fit if you want small-town life without much yard work.
Country properties
Acreage, outbuildings, and privacy. Expect a well and septic system and plan inspections for both.
Hobby farms and land
Ask about zoning, fencing, barn condition, and whether mineral rights transfer with the property.
Schools and Getting Around
Schools
The Sugarcreek area is served by Garaway Local Schools. The district is part of village life, and it even shows up at the Ohio Swiss Festival with events for the kids.
Country properties around Sugarcreek can fall in neighboring districts, so confirm the district for the exact address.
Commute and distances
State Route 39 is the main road. It runs east to Dover and I-77 in about 20–25 minutes, and west into Holmes County toward Walnut Creek and Berlin.
Canton is roughly 45 minutes to an hour away. Expect slower traffic on busy tourist weekends, and keep an eye out for buggies, especially after dark.
Local Highlights
A few things that make Sugarcreek, well, Sugarcreek:
The cuckoo clock
The giant clock in the center of town plays music and has dancing figures. Visitors stop for photos all day long.
Age of Steam Roundhouse
A working railroad roundhouse museum with a big collection of steam locomotives. It’s open for public tours from spring through fall.
The Budget
The Budget newspaper has been published in Sugarcreek since 1890 and is read by Amish and Mennonite communities across the Americas.
Buyer Tips for Sugarcreek
Well and septic
Most country homes have private well water and septic. Get a water test and septic inspection, and check what the county requires at sale.
Be ready to move
Good homes with land don’t come up often here. Have your pre-approval and down payment lined up before you start looking.
Mineral rights and easements
Ask whether mineral rights convey, and look at the survey for driveways, shared lanes, or utility easements.
Here’s how to get pre-approved, plus my Complete Guide to Buying a Home in Tuscarawas & Coshocton Counties.
Sugarcreek Home Buying FAQ
Why is Sugarcreek called the Little Switzerland of Ohio?
Because of its Swiss heritage. You’ll see Swiss-style buildings downtown, one of the world’s largest cuckoo clocks, and the annual Ohio Swiss Festival.
How many people live in Sugarcreek, Ohio?
The 2020 Census counted 2,373 residents in the village of Sugarcreek.
What school district is Sugarcreek in?
The Sugarcreek area is served by Garaway Local Schools. Confirm the district for any country property, since lines can vary.
Can I find a home with acreage near Sugarcreek?
Yes, but they don’t come up often. Plan for well, septic, and mineral-rights questions, and be ready to move quickly when the right one lists.
How far is Sugarcreek from Dover and New Philadelphia?
About 20–25 minutes by car, mostly on State Route 39.
Want to Live in Sugarcreek?
I’m Matthias Sterzer, The German REALTOR® with Kaufman Realty & Auctions. Whether it’s a house in the village or a few acres out in the country, I’ll help you figure out what it’s really worth and what to check before you commit.
📞 Call/Text: 740-610-8725
📧 Email: matthias.sterzer@kaufmanrealty.com
OUR BROKERAGE
Kaufman Realty & Auctions
We’re proud to be part of Kaufman Realty & Auctions, a local name in real estate and auctions since 1975. Stop by the New Philadelphia office or give us a call.
Kaufman Realty & Auctions, New Philadelphia Office
224 Fair Avenue NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Office: (330) 602-4111
kaufmanrealty.com
Matthias Sterzer, REALTOR®
Call or text: 740-610-8725
Photo credits: Age of Steam Roundhouse: David Wilson, CC BY 4.0; Sugarcreek cuckoo clock: Kreuzfeld, CC BY-SA 4.0; The Budget office: Kreuzfeld, CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons photos cropped and resized. All other photos are from The German Realtor Team’s own media library.