THE GERMAN REALTOR · KAUFMAN REALTY & AUCTIONS
Homes for Sale in Newcomerstown, Ohio
Newcomerstown sits on the Tuscarawas River in the southwest corner of Tuscarawas County, right where I-77 meets U.S. 36. It’s halfway between New Philadelphia and Coshocton, and it has a lot of history for a small village. Here’s my honest take on buying here.
LIVING IN NEWCOMERSTOWN
What It’s Like to Live in Newcomerstown
Newcomerstown is a village of about 3,700 people with a compact downtown, its own school district, and easy interstate access. The name goes back to a Lenape (Delaware) town led by Netawatwees, known to traders as Newcomer, in the 1760s and 1770s.
The village is also proud of its sports history. Woody Hayes grew up here and graduated from Newcomerstown High School in 1931, and the high school’s address is now 1 Woody Hayes Drive. Baseball legend Cy Young is also connected to the area.
Because it sits between two county seats, Newcomerstown works for people who commute either way: New Philadelphia to the northeast or Coshocton to the west.
Newcomerstown at a Glance
3,702
Residents
2020 Census count
I-77
Interstate access
Exit 65 at U.S. 36
~27 min
To New Philadelphia
About 21 miles
~27 min
To Coshocton
About 18 miles on U.S. 36
Population figures are 2020 Census counts from the U.S. Census Bureau. Drive times are approximate and depend on route, traffic, and weather.
Newcomerstown Market Snapshot
Latest numbers coming soon. Call Matthias for a free price check.
Call or text 740-610-8725 and I’ll pull current sales for the exact street or home you’re curious about.
For county-wide numbers, see my Tuscarawas Market Update.
Neighborhoods and Housing in Newcomerstown
In the village you’ll find mostly older homes: two-story frame houses and some brick near downtown and along the main streets, with smaller ranches mixed in. Outside the village limits, the hills of Oxford and surrounding townships have more acreage and country property.
The Tuscarawas River runs along the village, so some lower areas are closer to the water than others. Check the flood map for the exact parcel before you make an offer.
In-village homes
Walkable to downtown and the schools on many streets, usually on city water and sewer. Older homes need a careful inspection plan.
Ranches and starter homes
Smaller one-floor homes come up regularly and often draw first-time buyers. Good condition and fair pricing make a big difference in how fast they sell.
Country property and acreage
More land, outbuildings, and privacy in the surrounding townships. Plan for well and septic inspections, and check access roads and any oil or gas lease history.
Schools and Getting Around
Schools
The village is served by Newcomerstown Exempted Village Schools. Some rural addresses nearby may be in a different district, including districts in Coshocton County.
Buckeye Career Center and Kent State University at Tuscarawas are in the New Philadelphia area, about half an hour away.
District lines don’t always match the mailing address, so if schools matter to you, confirm the district for the exact property before you buy.
Commute and distances
I-77 Exit 65 puts you on the interstate in minutes. Cambridge is about 30 minutes south, and New Philadelphia is roughly 25 to 30 minutes north.
U.S. 36 heads west to West Lafayette in about 15 to 20 minutes and Coshocton in about 25 to 30. Columbus is roughly two hours away.
Local Highlights
Newcomerstown spots I send visitors to:
Temperance Tavern Museum
An 1841 canal-era tavern run by the Newcomerstown Historical Society, with a Woody Hayes room upstairs and exhibits on local history. Plan a visit.
Friday Night Football
Newcomerstown has more than a century of high school football history, and the stadium sits on Woody Hayes Drive. A fall game is a good way to get a feel for the town.
The Tuscarawas River
The river runs right along the village. It’s part of the canal-era history here, and a good reason to check flood maps when you shop.
Buyer Tips for Newcomerstown
Plan the inspection around age
For older homes, I like to see a sewer line scope plus a close look at the roof, foundation, and electrical panel.
Ask about mineral rights
Out in the country, ask whether oil, gas, or mineral rights transfer with the property and whether there’s an active lease.
Compare taxes by address
The village and nearby townships have different levies. The Tuscarawas County Auditor’s site shows taxes for each parcel, so compare before you offer.
Before you write an offer, read Top Homebuyer Mistakes in Ohio (and How to Avoid Them) and my Complete Guide to Buying a Home in Tuscarawas & Coshocton Counties. Thinking of selling instead? Grab my free home seller’s guide.
Newcomerstown Home Buying FAQ
Where is Newcomerstown, Ohio?
Newcomerstown is a village on the Tuscarawas River in southwest Tuscarawas County, at the I-77 and U.S. 36 interchange (Exit 65), between New Philadelphia and Coshocton.
How many people live in Newcomerstown?
The 2020 Census counted 3,702 residents in the village.
What school district serves Newcomerstown?
Newcomerstown Exempted Village Schools serves the village. Confirm the district for any specific address, especially rural ones.
How far is Newcomerstown from Coshocton and New Philadelphia?
Both are roughly 25 to 30 minutes by car: Coshocton to the west on U.S. 36, New Philadelphia to the northeast via I-77.
What are homes selling for in Newcomerstown?
Prices change with the market, so call or text Matthias Sterzer at 740-610-8725 for a free, current price check.
Who can help me buy or sell a home in Newcomerstown?
Call or text Matthias Sterzer with Kaufman Realty & Auctions at 740-610-8725. I work both Tuscarawas and Coshocton counties, which helps when you’re shopping on both sides of the line.
Keep Reading
See also: Coshocton homes for sale · West Lafayette homes for sale · New Philadelphia homes for sale · All Tuscarawas County towns
Looking at Homes in Newcomerstown?
I’m Matthias Sterzer, The German REALTOR® with Kaufman Realty & Auctions. I work with buyers and sellers on both sides of the Tuscarawas–Coshocton line, and I’ll tell you honestly what I see in each house, in town or out in the country.
📞 Call/Text: 740-610-8725
📧 Email: matthias.sterzer@kaufmanrealty.com
OUR BROKERAGE
Kaufman Realty & Auctions
We’re proud to be part of Kaufman Realty & Auctions, a local name in real estate and auctions since 1975. Stop by the New Philadelphia office or give us a call.
Kaufman Realty & Auctions, New Philadelphia Office
224 Fair Avenue NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663
Office: (330) 602-4111
kaufmanrealty.com
Matthias Sterzer, REALTOR®
Call or text: 740-610-8725
Photo credits: Saint Paul Lutheran Church: Roseohioresident, CC BY-SA 4.0; Newcomerstown High School: Roseohioresident, CC BY-SA 4.0. Wikimedia Commons photos cropped and resized. All other photos are from The German Realtor Team’s own media library.