Should I Sell My House at Auction or List It in Tuscarawas County?

In Tuscarawas County, a traditional listing fits sellers who want flexibility and room to negotiate. A Kaufman auction fits sellers who want a set timeline, as-is terms, and buyers competing on price while you set the rules. We choose after we look at condition, timing, and equity — not after a sales pitch.

Quick answer

Neither path is ‘better.’ Listing leaves the end date open and lets you weigh offers. Auction sets a calendar: you decide the terms, buyers decide the price. I’ll put both on one page and tell you which I’d use if it were my house.

I’m Matthias Sterzer, The German Realtor® with Kaufman Realty & Auctions. I help sellers in Dover, New Philadelphia, Uhrichsville, Sugarcreek, and across Tuscarawas and Coshocton counties. I’m not an auctioneer. I work with Kaufman’s auctioneers, including Aaron Yoder (330-204-4114), when auction is the right tool. Aaron is the auctioneer — including on contents or consignment auctions. I’m the Realtor.

Quick compare: list vs. auction

Here’s the short version I draw on a notepad:

  • Listing: you set an asking price, negotiate, and stay on the market until a contract works — or until you change strategy.
  • Auction: you set the terms (often absolute, as-is, no financing contingencies). Buyers bid. The marketing window and close follow a posted calendar.
  • Typical no-survey auction path: about 60 days (roughly 30 days of marketing + about a 30-day close).
  • Survey needed: often about 90–120 days.

I don’t have a fresh Tuscarawas County-wide market snapshot I’m willing to treat as current — the county figures still on the site are from early 2026. I won’t recycle those as if they were today’s numbers. Town-level MLS Now last-360-days figures as of Nov. 5, 2026, include Dover ($269,803 average, 61 days on market, 205 sales) and Sugarcreek ($339,393 average, 57 days on market, 29 sales). Useful context. Not a verdict on your house.

There are two kinds of auction I explain up front. In an absolute auction, the property sells at whatever price the auction brings. In a reserve auction, if bidding does not reach at least the seller’s reserve amount, it’s a no sale. That’s the distinction. I don’t add other cancellation claims on top of that.

Who usually prefers a listing in Dover, New Philly, Uhrichsville

A listing usually fits when the house shows well, you can carry it for a while, and you want control over the asking price and which offer you take. It also fits when a typical buyer will need a regular mortgage and you want room to negotiate repairs or closing dates.

If you’re in Dover, New Philadelphia, or elsewhere in Tuscarawas County, and the home is a straightforward in-town property, listing is often the first tool I reach for — unless your timeline says otherwise.

Who usually prefers auction

Auction often fits when you want a date you can tell family, when the house should be sold as-is, when several decision-makers need a process that feels even, or when the property is unusual — acreage, outbuildings, multiple parcels.

It is not reserved for ‘bad’ houses. It’s a way to let buyers compete on price under rules you set in advance.

A seller once told me, “Matthias, I trust you, just take it from here. I don’t want to deal with this house anymore.” That’s a real, anonymous line, and it’s the fork I see a lot: some people want help finishing a house they are done with. If the house should be sold as-is, or the seller just wants it gone, a Kaufman auction can be the cleaner path — the same way we helped a client who was done with his house, brought in B&L Dumpster for the cleanout, pulled carpets and found hardwood, and had a final clean before professional photos. He was really happy with the results. Aaron Yoder (330-204-4114) is the auctioneer. I’m the Realtor.

Timeline: about 60 days typical (no survey) vs. 90–120 with survey

With Kaufman’s auctioneers, plan on a marketing period so buyers can inspect and get comfortable with the terms, then auction day, then a closing period. For a typical home with no new survey, that’s often about 60 days start to finish. If the property has more acreage or may sell as more than one parcel, a new survey can stretch the path to about 90–120 days, depending on the surveyor.

I explain the same calendar in the family-sale context in auction or list a parent’s home (a Coshocton County story, same decision).

How we decide together (no pressure)

We walk the property, talk about your move date, look at condition and any survey question, and sketch both nets and both calendars. If listing is the better tool, we list. If auction is the better tool, I bring in Kaufman’s auctioneers and stay with you as your agent. If the honest answer is ‘clean it out first, then decide,’ we do that.

Stuck between ‘list it’ and ‘auction it’? Call or text 740-610-8725. We’ll map both on one page. The free Home Seller’s Guide is ready when you are.

Frequently asked questions

Is auction only for distressed homes?

No. Distress is one reason people choose auction, not the definition of it. I also see auction used for inherited houses, properties that are fine but as-is, unusual acreage, or sellers who want a date. Condition matters. It isn’t a character judgment.

Can I still live in the house during marketing?

Often yes, if we plan preview access and spell out possession in the terms. Buyers need a fair chance to see the property. We’ll write the move-out date so it isn’t a surprise.

What does an absolute sale mean?

In an absolute auction, the property sells at whatever price the auction brings. In a reserve auction, if bidding does not reach at least the seller’s reserve amount, it’s a no sale. Aaron Yoder can walk you through which terms fit before you sign.

Are you the auctioneer?

No. I’m a real estate agent. Real estate auctions with Kaufman are conducted by Kaufman Realty & Auctions’ auctioneers. I help you decide whether that path fits and I stay involved as your agent.

How long does the auction path take in Tuscarawas County?

The same framework I use in Coshocton County: about 60 days for a typical home with no new survey, and about 90–120 days if a survey is needed, depending on the surveyor.

Matthias and Justina Sterzer, serving Tuscarawas and Coshocton Counties, Ohio, with Kaufman Realty & Auctions.
Kaufman Realty & Auctions and The German Realtor Team logo

Call or text me at 740-610-8725. I’ll map listing and auction side by side for your Tuscarawas County property — no pressure to pick in the first conversation. Free Home Seller’s Guide.

Matthias Sterzer, The German Realtor® | Kaufman Realty & Auctions
Email: matthias.sterzer@kaufmanrealty.com

Matthias Sterzer, The German Realtor®, Kaufman Realty & Auctions. Matthias is a real estate agent, not an auctioneer; auctions are conducted by Kaufman Realty & Auctions’ auctioneers. This article is general information, not legal or tax advice.


Thinking about buying or selling in Tuscarawas or Coshocton County? Call or text me at 740-610-8725 — I’m happy to help. Matthias Sterzer, Kaufman Realty & Auctions.